Legacy TOEFL Writing: Complete Guide

Introduction to TOEFL Writing

The TOEFL Writing section previously consisted of two tasks: the Integrated Writing task, which required test-takers to read a passage, listen to a recording, and then write a response, and the Independent Writing task, where they crafted an essay based on a prompt. This format allowed candidates a total of 50 minutes to complete both tasks, with 20 minutes dedicated to the Integrated task and 30 minutes to the Independent task.

As of July 26, 2023, significant changes were implemented (click here to read more about the 2024 format of the TOEFL test) to enhance the relevance of the test to academic settings. While the Integrated Writing task remains unchanged, it is now accompanied by a new component: the Writing for an Academic Discussion task. In this new format, candidates will participate in an online discussion, requiring them to respond to prompts by articulating their opinions and building on points made by others. This task is designed to better reflect the interactive nature of academic discourse and emphasizes critical thinking and engagement.

The updated structure allows candidates a total of 29 minutes to complete both tasks: 20 minutes for the Integrated Writing task and 10 minutes for the new Academic Discussion task. This change aims to streamline the testing process while ensuring that the evaluation remains rigorous and relevant to university-level expectations. Here is a complete guide with free sample questions, answers, writing examples, and explanations for the new TOEFL Writing Task (Academic Discussion), which was added recently.

For more information regarding the changes in the TOEFL Writing section, you can check out this page on the ETS official website.

"Why is the TOEFL Writing Section So Hard?"

In my experience, the writing section is the most challenging part of the TOEFL for many students. Unlike reading and listening, where students often have more exposure to English in daily life, writing is a skill that requires deliberate practice. Many students struggle because they don’t practice writing regularly, making it harder to organize thoughts, use correct grammar, and develop ideas under the exam’s time constraints

Another common challenge is the Integrated Writing task, where students must summarize information from both a passage and a lecture. It’s difficult to keep personal tones and opinions out of this task, as the focus should be entirely on presenting the information objectively. This can be especially tricky for those who are more accustomed to writing personal essays or opinion pieces.

TOEFL Writing Task 1: Strategies, Tips & Tricks, and Secrets for Success

DO!

1. Summarize Key Points ✔️

Your primary task in the Integrated Writing section is to summarize the key points from both the reading passage and the lecture, showing how they relate to each other. The structure of these texts often follows predictable patterns. For example, the reading might present a central idea or problem, followed by several supporting reasons or solutions. The lecture might then provide examples, offer counterarguments, or reinforce specific aspects of the reading.

Example:

Reading Passage:
“The introduction of electric cars is essential to reduce urban air pollution. Electric cars produce no emissions, making them an environmentally friendly alternative to gasoline-powered vehicles. Furthermore, as technology advances, the cost of electric cars is expected to decrease, making them more accessible to the average consumer. Finally, government incentives, such as tax rebates, will further encourage the adoption of electric vehicles.”

Lecture:
“While electric cars do indeed produce no emissions during operation, the environmental benefits are not as clear-cut as they seem. The production of electric car batteries involves mining rare minerals, which has its own environmental impact. Additionally, the electricity used to charge these cars often comes from fossil fuels, which still contribute to air pollution. Although government incentives make electric cars more attractive, the high initial costs and limited range remain significant barriers to widespread adoption.”

In your essay, you would summarize the reading’s main points (electric cars reduce pollution, are becoming more affordable, and are supported by government incentives) and contrast them with the lecturer’s concerns (environmental impact of battery production, reliance on fossil fuel-based electricity, and the limitations of electric cars). This approach shows a clear understanding of both perspectives.

2. Plan Your Response ✔️

Before you begin writing, take a few minutes to organize your thoughts and plan your response. Identify the key points from both the reading passage and the lecture, and decide how you will structure your essay. A well-planned response is easier to write and ensures that your essay has a clear, logical flow. Think about how you will connect the information from the two sources, and outline your paragraphs to cover each main point effectively.

Example of a Good Plan for TOEFL Writing Task 1:

2.1. Review the Sources (2-3 minutes)

Reading Passage: Identify the main idea, key points, and supporting details. Take note of how these points are structured (e.g., problem-solution, statement-reason).

Lecture: Listen carefully to understand the key points and how they relate to the reading passage. Note any points that agree with, contradict, or add to the information in the reading.

2.2. Outline Your Response (2-3 minutes)

Introduction: Briefly introduce the topic. State that you will summarize the main points from both the reading and the lecture, highlighting their relationship.

Body Paragraph 1:Main Point from Reading: Summarize the first key point from the reading passage. Related Information from Lecture: Describe how the lecture supports or contradicts this point.

Body Paragraph 2:Main Point from Reading: Summarize the second key point from the reading passage. Related Information from Lecture: Explain how the lecture supports or contradicts this point.

Body Paragraph 3 (if needed):Additional Point from Reading: Summarize any additional key points from the reading passage. Related Information from Lecture: Discuss how the lecture addresses or adds to this point.

Conclusion: Briefly recap the main points discussed. Summarize the overall relationship between the reading and the lecture.

2.3. Write the Response (20 minutes)

Follow your outline, making sure each paragraph is clear and logically organized. Use academic language and paraphrase the information from the sources. Ensure that you are objective and focused on summarizing the information without personal opinions.

2.4. Review and Edit (4-5 minutes)

Check for any grammatical or spelling errors. Ensure that all key points are covered and that the response flows logically. Verify that your writing accurately reflects the information from both the reading and the lecture.

✍️ Now let’s write a real response based on the example plan for TOEFL Writing Task 1. We’ll use the electric cars example from above:

Introduction: The reading passage and the lecture both discuss electric cars, focusing on their benefits and limitations. The passage highlights their advantages, while the lecture offers a critical perspective.

Body Paragraph 1: The reading argues that electric cars reduce urban air pollution by producing no emissions. However, the lecture points out that battery production involves mining rare minerals and that electricity for charging often comes from fossil fuels, which still contributes to pollution.

Body Paragraph 2: The passage claims that technological advancements will lower the cost of electric cars and that government incentives will boost adoption. The lecture counters by noting that high costs and limited range remain barriers, and incentives alone may not address these issues effectively.

Body Paragraph 3: Additionally, the reading emphasizes that government incentives will make electric cars more appealing. The lecture argues that while incentives help, they do not solve problems related to battery production and energy sources, limiting their impact on adoption.

Conclusion: In summary, the reading highlights the benefits of electric cars, including reduced emissions and incentives, while the lecture provides a critical view of environmental impacts, high costs, and the limitations of incentives.

3. Stay Objective ✔️

It’s essential to maintain an objective tone throughout your essay. The Integrated Writing task requires you to present information from the sources without injecting your own opinions or personal thoughts. Stick to the facts and focus on accurately conveying the relationship between the reading passage and the lecture. This can be challenging, especially if you have strong opinions on the topic, but remember that your score depends on how well you present the information provided, not on your personal views.

4. Paraphrase Information ✔️

Paraphrasing is crucial in the Integrated Writing task. Instead of copying sentences directly from the reading passage or lecture, rephrase the information in your own words. This demonstrates your understanding of the material and your ability to manipulate language effectively. For example, if the reading passage states, “The new policy significantly reduces emissions,” you could paraphrase it as, “The recently implemented policy leads to a marked decrease in emissions.” Always aim to capture the original meaning without repeating the exact wording.

5. Use Academic Language ✔️

Your response should be written in formal, academic language. This means avoiding slang, contractions, or overly casual expressions. Instead, use precise vocabulary and varied sentence structures to convey your ideas. For instance, instead of writing “The lecture says…” you might write, “According to the lecture…” Maintaining a professional tone enhances the credibility of your writing and aligns with the expectations of the TOEFL examiners.

DON'T!

1. Don’t Include Personal Opinions ❌

The Integrated Writing task requires you to objectively summarize and compare the information presented in the reading passage and the lecture. Including your own opinions detracts from the task and can lead to a lower score. This section tests your ability to convey others’ ideas, not your personal views.

Examples:

❌Incorrect: “I believe this change will be effective because it aligns with environmental goals.”
✔️Correct: “The reading passage suggests that this change will be effective due to its alignment with environmental goals.”

❌Incorrect: “In my opinion, the lecturer’s point about battery production is more convincing.”
✔️Correct: “The lecturer argues that battery production has significant environmental impacts, challenging the reading’s positive outlook.”

2. Don’t Overcomplicate Your Writing ❌

Using overly complex sentences or advanced vocabulary can sometimes backfire, especially if it makes your writing unclear or difficult to follow. The primary goal is clarity and coherence. Simple, well-structured sentences can be more effective than convoluted ones. Focus on clearly conveying the key points from the sources. Keep it simple!

Examples:

❌Overcomplicated: “The promulgation of electric vehicles, as elucidated by the lecturer, notwithstanding its apparent reduction in gaseous emissions, engenders multifaceted repercussions vis-à-vis the environmental stratagems.”
✔️Simplified: “The lecturer explains that while electric cars reduce emissions, they also have complex environmental impacts.”

❌Overcomplicated: “Notwithstanding the irrefutable advantages posited in the reading passage, the lecturer articulates counterarguments of considerable merit.”
✔️Simplified: “Although the reading highlights clear benefits, the lecturer provides strong counterarguments.”

3. Don’t Copy Text Verbatim ❌

Copying phrases or sentences directly from the reading passage or the lecture can significantly lower your score. The TOEFL Writing section assesses your ability to paraphrase and synthesize information. Even if a particular phrase seems perfect, rephrase it in your own words to demonstrate your understanding.

Examples:

❌Verbatim: “Electric cars are essential to reduce urban air pollution.”
✔️Paraphrased: “The passage argues that electric vehicles play a crucial role in cutting down air pollution in cities.”

❌Verbatim: “The production of electric car batteries involves mining rare minerals.”
✔️Paraphrased: “The lecturer highlights that the manufacturing process for electric car batteries requires the extraction of scarce minerals.”

4. Don’t Focus on Unrelated Details ❌

Including details that aren’t directly related to the main points of the reading passage and lecture can weaken your response. Your goal is to focus on the core arguments and counterarguments presented in the sources. Irrelevant information can distract the reader and dilute the effectiveness of your essay.

Examples:

❌Incorrect: “The reading passage briefly mentions that electric cars are quiet, which might reduce noise pollution in urban areas.”
✔️Correct: “The reading passage emphasizes that electric cars are vital for reducing air pollution, while the lecture questions this by pointing out the environmental costs of battery production.”

❌Incorrect: “The lecturer talks about the general benefits of technological advancements, which could apply to various industries.”
✔️Correct: “The lecturer specifically counters the claim that technology will make electric cars more affordable by highlighting ongoing high production costs.”

5. Don’t Rush Without Revising ❌

Submitting your essay without reviewing it first can lead to easily avoidable mistakes that could lower your score. Take a few minutes to read through your response, checking for grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, and ensuring that your essay directly addresses the task. Even a quick revision can significantly improve the quality of your writing.

Examples:

❌Without Revising: “The reading suggest that electric cars will decrease pollution, but the lecture argue that battery production is harmful.”
✔️Revised: “The reading suggests that electric cars will decrease pollution, but the lecture argues that battery production is harmful.”

❌Without Revising: “Electric cars produce no emissions, but the lector mention that charging them relies on fossil fuels.”
✔️Revised: “Electric cars produce no emissions, but the lecturer mentions that charging them relies on fossil fuels.”

TOEFL Task 1 [Integrated Writing] Free Sample Video

TOEFL Writing Task 2: Strategies, Tips & Tricks, and Secrets for Success (New Academic Discussion Task)

In the July 2023 TOEFL update, a significant change was introduced to the Writing section with the addition of the Writing for an Academic Discussion task. In this new format, you are required to contribute to an ongoing academic discussion by writing a concise and well-structured response to a prompt within 10 minutes. The task focuses on your ability to present clear, logical arguments supported by relevant examples. This is a shift from summarization to engaging with a debate, making it essential to respond thoughtfully, demonstrate critical analysis, and maintain clarity under time pressure.

This “Do and Don’t” guide will help you effectively navigate the new format by offering practical advice on how to structure your response, avoid common pitfalls, and enhance your writing to meet the TOEFL scoring criteria.

DO!

1. Understand the Prompt and Classmates' Responses ✔️

Before writing, make sure you thoroughly understand both the professor’s question and your classmates’ responses. Your job is to contribute to the discussion, so you need to know what points have already been made and how they are argued. This way, you can provide a relevant and thoughtful response. If you misinterpret the prompt or the responses, your contribution might seem out of place or irrelevant.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: The professor asks about improving skills for current jobs, but you write about job satisfaction instead.
✔️ Correct: If the professor asks about skill development, respond by discussing specific skills, such as leadership or technical abilities.

2. Contribute New Ideas to the Discussion ✔️

Your response should either build on existing ideas or introduce something new. This might mean agreeing with one classmate and adding further support, or disagreeing and providing counterarguments. Always ensure that your contribution moves the conversation forward, rather than simply repeating points that have already been made.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “I agree that employees should focus on future skills.” (This is too vague and doesn’t add anything new.)
✔️ Correct: “I agree that future skills are important, but I also think it’s crucial to refresh rarely used skills from our current jobs. For example, updating coding skills can keep employees competitive in their current roles.”

3. Be Concise and Stay on Topic ✔️

Since you only have 10 minutes to write, it’s important to stay focused. Avoid going off on tangents or adding irrelevant details. Keep your response centered on the professor’s question and your classmates’ points. A well-organized and focused response will be clearer and more effective than one that tries to cover too much.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “While it’s important to learn new skills, employees also need more vacation time to prevent burnout.” (This introduces a different topic.)
✔️ Correct: “While new skills are essential for career growth, focusing only on future skills can leave employees unprepared for their current roles.”

4. Use Clear and Simple Language ✔️

Your response needs to be easy to understand. Don’t use overly complex vocabulary or sentence structures that might confuse the reader. Instead, focus on communicating your ideas clearly and logically. Simple, precise language is much more effective in timed writing tasks.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “In this multifarious and ever-evolving occupational ecosystem, one must incessantly ameliorate one’s capabilities.”
✔️ Correct: “In today’s fast-changing job market, it’s important to continually improve your skills.”

5. Address Both Sides of the Argument (if relevant) ✔️

Sometimes the professor’s question will have two sides, and it’s useful to acknowledge both in your response. If your classmates have different opinions, consider addressing both sides before stating your position. This will make your contribution more balanced and comprehensive.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “We should only focus on future skills because that’s what will matter in the long run.”
✔️ Correct: “While future skills are important, focusing solely on them could mean neglecting current responsibilities. It’s important to balance both.”

DON'T!

1. Don’t Simply Agree Without Adding Value ❌

It’s not enough to simply say you agree or disagree with a classmate. You need to explain why and add new information to the conversation. This shows the ability to think critically and develop ideas further.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “I agree with Sarah. Employees should focus on their future skills.” (This adds nothing new.)
✔️ Correct: “I agree with Sarah’s point about future skills. However, I would argue that focusing on industry-specific skills will help employees stay competitive in the job market.”

2. Don’t Include Personal Opinions or Experiences ❌

Although you’re participating in a discussion, this task still requires you to maintain an academic tone. Avoid personal anecdotes or overly subjective opinions, as the focus should remain on the topic, not your personal experiences. Your goal is to contribute to an academic discussion, not share personal stories.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “In my experience, learning new skills helped me get a promotion.”
✔️ Correct: “Learning new skills can lead to career advancement, as many industries prioritize candidates with up-to-date knowledge.”

3. Don’t Overcomplicate Your Writing ❌

While it’s good to show that you can use varied vocabulary and grammar, overly complex sentences can reduce clarity. If your response becomes too difficult to follow, it could hurt your score. Stick to clear, straightforward sentences that express your ideas effectively.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “The manifold exigencies of the contemporary workplace necessitate a plethora of capabilities.”
✔️ Correct: “Today’s workplace requires employees to have a variety of skills.”

4. Don’t Ignore Grammar and Sentence Structure ❌

Even though you’re writing quickly, grammatical accuracy and clear sentence structure are important. Mistakes that make your writing hard to understand will negatively impact your score. After writing, if you have time, review your work to catch any obvious errors.

Example:
❌ Incorrect: “The companeis need to give all employees chance to attend trainings, this will improve future skills and current skills. But some employees they don’t want.”
✔️ Correct: “Companies should provide all employees with training opportunities. This will improve both their future and current skills, even for those who may be reluctant at first.”

TOEFL Writing Task 1: Sample Questions

TOEFL Writing Task 2: Sample Questions

OUR TOEFL SHOP

TOEFL Preparation

Listening

Reading

Writing

Speaking

Vocabulary

Basic

Prefixes

Roots

Suffixes