TOEFL Academic Discussion Practice 012

Writing task
Professor
“Our recent discussions have focused on the use of paper straws in the ongoing debate about plastic waste reduction. Some advocates claim that switching to paper straws represents a meaningful initiative toward sustainability. In contrast, critics argue that this shift is merely a superficial response to a much larger problem of pollution. Considering these perspectives, do you believe that paper straws serve a significant purpose in promoting environmental protection, or are they simply a facade that distracts from more substantial solutions?”
Student A
Vahid
“I believe paper straws are a pointless solution to a bigger problem. While they seem like an environmentally friendly option, they don’t really make a significant difference. The same people who push for these straws often fly around in private jets, contributing way more pollution than a plastic straw ever could. It feels hypocritical to focus on such a minor change while ignoring the much larger sources of pollution. If we want to make a real impact, we need to tackle the major contributors to environmental damage, not just swap out our straws.”
Student B
Luna
“I see Vahid’s point, but I think using paper straws can still have some positive effects. Sure, it’s frustrating that some advocates don’t practice what they preach, but that doesn’t mean we should abandon the idea altogether. Using alternatives to plastic can raise awareness about pollution and inspire others to make better choices. Even if the wealthy continue to pollute significantly, we can still contribute to a cleaner environment through small changes, like using paper straws, which can set a precedent for larger shifts in consumer behavior.”
Write a post that contributes to the discussion. Express and support your opinion in your own words. An effective response will contain at least 100 words.